- Open Access
Bimodal Whole-Mount Imaging of Tendon Using Confocal Microscopy and X-ray Micro-Computed Tomography
Biological Procedures Online volume 22, Article number: 13 (2020)
Three-dimensional imaging modalities for optically dense connective tissues such as tendons are limited and typically have a single imaging methodological endpoint. Here, we have developed a bimodal procedure utilising fluorescence-based confocal microscopy and x-ray micro-computed tomography for the imaging of adult tendons to visualise and analyse extracellular sub-structure and cellular composition in small and large animal species.
Using fluorescent immunolabelling and optical clearing, we visualised the expression of the novel cross-species marker of tendon basement membrane, laminin-α4 in 3D throughout whole rat Achilles tendons and equine superficial digital flexor tendon 5 mm segments. This revealed a complex network of laminin-α4 within the tendon core that predominantly localises to the interfascicular matrix compartment. Furthermore, we implemented a chemical drying process capable of creating contrast densities enabling visualisation and quantification of both fascicular and interfascicular matrix volume and thickness by x-ray micro-computed tomography. We also demonstrated that both modalities can be combined using reverse clarification of fluorescently labelled tissues prior to chemical drying to enable bimodal imaging of a single sample.
Whole-mount imaging of tendon allowed us to identify the presence of an extensive network of laminin-α4 within tendon, the complexity of which cannot be appreciated using traditional 2D imaging techniques. Creating contrast for x-ray micro-computed tomography imaging of tendon using chemical drying is not only simple and rapid, but also markedly improves on previously published methods. Combining these methods provides the ability to gain spatio-temporal information and quantify tendon substructures to elucidate the relationship between morphology and function.
Advances in 3-dimensional (3D) imaging of dense connective tissues such as tendons are essential for the investigation of normal tissue structure as well as musculoskeletal diseases in pre-clinical models and clinical samples. Recent developments in 3D microscopy and scanning techniques have permitted imaging of cells and structures of calcified tissues, whole embryos, and organisms, using methods including phase-contrast x-ray micro-computed tomography (μ-CT), optical projection tomography and label-free detection methods [1,2,3]. However, 3D imaging by fluorescent methods remains a challenge for adult tissues such as cartilage, ligaments and tendons, as their opacity and dense matrix composition renders deep imaging of whole connective tissues difficult. Paradoxically, μ-CT of non-calcified tissues is technically difficult due to their lower x-ray attenuation compared to mineralised tissues such as bone . Hence, there is a demand for imaging modalities that can be used to study the gross structure of connective tissues as well as the spatial organisation of extracellular matrix (ECM) and its inter-relationships with resident cell populations.
Until recently, imaging techniques to investigate both structural and cellular elements of dense collagenous tissues such as adult tendon have been limited to conventional 2D methods. These only allow appreciation of tissue structure in a single plane or require extensive reconstruction , and are time-consuming, labour-intensive, and destructive, often creating artefacts within tissue . Recent advances in optical clearing agents have provided scope to clarify tissues, either by dehydration, delipidation, matching tissue refractive index or a combination of each, to allow 3D visualisation of ECM organisation and cell populations in both mineralised and non-mineralised tissues [7,8,9,10,11]. A plethora of clearing agents are now commercially available, with a number of studies describing their effectiveness for fluorescent imaging of connective tissues with varying degrees of success [12,13,14,15]. In addition, reversing optical clarification of collagenous structures is possible with a variety of aqueous compounds, such as rehydration by saline-based solutions of glycerol or benzyl benzoate based clearing agents [13, 16]. Visikol® HISTO™ is a clearing agent reversible by ethanol which has only minor effects on tissue structure , with recent studies able to reverse tissue clearing for histological imaging post-3D imaging [18, 19]. Therefore, the reversibility of clarification agents introduces a new potential to better integrate different imaging modalities to resolve tissue structure and cell-ECM relationships. Further, the ability to image the same sample using the distinct modalities described herein has the potential to reduce the number of animals required and therefore contribute to more humane animal research, according to the 3Rs principles which necessitate Replacement, Reduction and Refinement of animal usage .
To the authors’ knowledge, no study to date has attempted to establish bimodal procedures to image fluorescently labelled soft tissues in 3D and apply a distinct modality, such as μ-CT, to assess gross structural parameters quantitatively. Hence, post-clarification imaging by μ-CT could provide a new avenue for soft tissue research to investigate structure-function relationships in conjunction with 3D immunolabelling approaches. However, contrast-enhanced 3D imaging in soft tissues remains difficult due to current strategies being limited by long perfusion times and an inability to fully resolve tissue structure due to insufficient contrast. Recent studies have described procedures to image soft tissues such as tendon with μ-CT using common aqueous contrast agents for such as iodine potassium iodide (I2KI; also referred to as Lugol’s solution) and phosphotungstic acid . However, acidic agents such as phosphotungstic acid require high concentrations to create contrast which can erode samples and distort structure in soft tissues, whereas iodine-based agents require variable incubation times and may ultimately provide inadequate contrast to visualise and segment soft tissue sub-structures . Hence, alternatives such as chemical and critical point drying should be considered, given both methods have been shown to generate excellent contrast in soft tissues [22,23,24,25,26]. Recent advances have exploited chemical drying by hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS) to generate contrast for 3D visualisation of soft tissue internal structure, although this technique has yet to be applied to tendon [27, 28].
Combining imaging that reveals internal structure of connective tissues with markers of cell-ECM specialisation in a single sample is an attractive possibility. In tendons, a number of fibrous proteins, proteoglycans, and glycoproteins that comprise basement membranes have been shown to localise to the interfascicular matrix (IFM), which surrounds tendon fascicles (reviewed in ). Basement membranes are highly specialised ECMs that interact with cell surface receptors, and are integral to progenitor cell niches, governing fate determination and structural integrity in musculoskeletal tissues (reviewed in  and ). Laminin is an essential basement membrane glycoprotein that interacts with cell adhesion molecules and cell surface receptors to regulate various cellular and molecular processes [32, 33]. In tendon, laminin and other basement membrane-associated proteins have been described previously [34, 35], with recent proteomic studies identifying numerous laminin subunits, including laminin-α4 (LAMA4), localised to the IFM . However, the 3D organisation and composition of basement membrane proteins within the tendon core has yet to be described. Therefore, we utilised a novel cross-species marker of tendon basement membrane, LAMA4, combined with optical clearing techniques, to visualise 3D organisation of structural components in tendon.
Given the demand for 3D imaging modalities for dense connective tissues, we developed techniques for whole-mount confocal microscopy and x-ray micro-computed tomography to achieve 3D visualisation and analysis of adult tendons. Furthermore, we aimed to develop a method applicable to tissues from both small and large animal models, testing our method in a rat (Rattus norvegicus) and equine (Equus caballus) tendon. Next, we developed a workflow for bimodal single sample imaging, combining our confocal and μ-CT imaging methodologies to visualise cellular and structural properties of tendon in 3D.
To develop a method that enables both fluorescent imaging of cell-ECM architecture and x-ray scanning of dense connective tissue structure, we combined multiple processes to create a workflow that integrates whole-mount immunolabelling, reversible optical clarification, and subsequent chemical drying to enable bimodal 3D imaging of tendon by confocal microscopy and μ-CT (Fig. 1). We applied this technique to whole rat Achilles tendons and segments of equine superficial digital flexor tendons (SDFT). A more detailed schematic describing data analysis workflows for each independent method is provided in the supplementary information (Figure S1).
Prior to 3D imaging, appropriate antibody concentrations were identified and expression of LAMA4 was confirmed in both rat Achilles and equine SDFT using traditional 2D fluorescent immunolabelling of tendon sections (Figure S2). Thereafter, we performed tissue immunolabelling and optical clarification with Visikol HISTO™ solutions to visualise 3D organisation of LAMA4 in whole rat Achilles and in segments of equine SDFT using confocal microscopy and optimised protocols based on size-specific guidelines provided by Visikol™. As tissue thickness was similar between both equine SDFT segments and rat Achilles tendon, initial immunolabelling steps, including washing, permeabilisation, detergent washes and blocking were performed for identical periods of times. The main difference between protocols were antibody concentrations, which differed based on initial optimisations using thin tissue sections. The entire protocol, including nuclei counterstaining and dehydration steps prior to optical clarification requires a minimum of 12 days with no stopping points.
Based on our optimised protocol, clarification rendered both SDFT segments and whole rat Achilles transparent within 4.5 days. This was achieved with minimal clearing times (SDFT = 72 h; rat Achilles = 108 h) according to the manufacturer’s guidelines. Longer clearing times were selected for the rat Achilles as lower permeability was expected due to the presence of the epi- and para-tenons on the tendon surface, which have been shown to act as a retentive barrier . If necessary, clarification steps can be extended without negatively affecting labelling or tissue integrity. Using 3D projections of image stacks acquired by confocal imaging, we were able to visualise widespread vessel-like organisation of the structures labelled positively for basement membrane protein LAMA4 within the rat Achilles and equine SDFT (Figs. 2 and 4); information that cannot be gained from traditional 2D imaging. In the rat Achilles, LAMA4 expression was localised to the tendon surface and structures with a distribution likely to comprise the IFM (Figs. 2 and 3). In equine SDFT segments taken from the tendon core, the majority of LAMA4 labelling was seemingly consistent with IFM with some LAMA4 deposition in fascicles (Fig. 4). Our method achieved imaging depths of at least 200 μm in equine SDFT and throughout an entire rat Achilles tendon (approximately 800 μm).
A key disadvantage to most commercially available optical clearing agents is the irreversibility of the clearing procedures. Here, we used an ethanol-based dehydration procedure for reverse clarification of Visikol HISTO™ solutions, followed by a previously described chemical drying process using HMDS to generate contrast for μ-CT . Using grey-scale images captured from reconstructed μ-CT tomograms of reverse cleared and dried samples, we demonstrated that HMDS drying provides excellent contrast capable of visualising tendon surface and core structure in both species. Additionally, false colour 3D volume rendering provides indication of relative densities and enhances visualisation of tendon internal structure (Figs. 5 and 6).
An important feature of these morphometric approaches is the scope they provide for detailed quantitative analysis of tissue organisation. To demonstrate this utility, we therefore used an automated segmentation procedure to separate both IFM and fascicle structures in equine SDFT. By adapting pre-existing measurement modalities used for routine 3D bone analyses , designed for measurement of bone parameters (see Table 1), we were able to record tendon volume (TV), IFM volume relative to tendon volume (IV/TV), and IFM thickness (IFM.th) (Fig. 7). To explore the possibility that such quantitative methods to assess tendon sub-structures may be impacted by artefacts introduced by optical clarification and reverse clearing, we scanned reverse cleared and non-cleared segments derived from the same tendon, that had both been HDMS-dried and compared IFM and tendon measurements. As expected, we found there was no difference in tendon volume as both samples (4.80–4.82 mm3) were analysed using the same volume-of-interest (1.75 mm × 1.75 × 2 mm). We found that reverse clarification had no obvious effect on tendon structure or IFM, as IFM volume did not differ markedly between the HMDS only (0.26 mm3) and reverse cleared, HMDS-dried tendon samples (0.31 mm3). With no stark difference between IFM volume observed, there were consequent similarities in IFM volume to tendon volume (IV/TV), with the HMDS-dried segment (5.5%) exhibiting similar relative IFM volume to the reverse cleared tendon (6.3%) segment. Furthermore, IFM thickness measurements also confirmed that reverse clarification had no adverse effect on tendon sub-structure analyses, with reverse cleared tendon exhibiting a similar IFM thickness (0.022 mm) compared to the IFM measured in the HMDS-dried segment (0.019 mm). Moreover, both conditions exhibited IFM thicknesses that fall within the range of previously reported IFM thickness measurements (0.01–0.025 mm) for an individual equine SDFT using 3D histological reconstructions . Hence, reversible clarification procedures appear to have no discernible effect on tendon sub-structure.
We present a technique combining whole-mount confocal microscopy and μ-CT for the imaging of adult tendon, using a reversible clearing approach that renders tissue transparent for confocal imaging, followed by reverse clarification and chemical drying that permits contrast-enhanced μ-CT. We have demonstrated that not only does our methodology provide independent fluorescence and x-ray-based imaging modalities for dense connective tissues in the adult, but also enables both modalities to be combined for bimodal imaging of a single sample. This approach overcomes the limitations of traditional disruptive serial sectioning and en bloc staining procedures, introducing methods for visualising tissue structure within a single sample at a meso- and microscopic scale to elucidate the relationship between cell and ECM in the context of tissue structure and function.
We applied our bimodal procedure to both rat and equine tendons to demonstrate that our method can be applied to small and large animal models. Hence, bimodal imaging offers the potential to image tendon structures for comparative biology purposes as well as for pathological conditions. Here, we used a novel marker of tendon basement membrane, LAMA4, to visualise equine and rat tendon sub-structure. LAMA4 is a component of laminin-8, laminin-9, and laminin-14, and has been described as a key regulator of basement membrane remodelling and function in adipose, cardiac, endothelial, hematopoietic, muscular, neuronal, and renal cell niches [40,41,42,43]. Our 3D imaging modality identified a complex network of LAMA4 immunolabelling in the core of tendons from both small and large animals, where it appears to localise predominantly to the IFM. This complexity can only be appreciated when viewing 3D reconstructions rather than 2D slices. Future studies could use our approach to visualise basement membrane remodelling and cell response to inflammation or injury in tendons and other soft tissues. However, there is an immediate need for robust workflows permitting relative 3D fluorescent quantification in whole-mount tissue imaging. Therefore, future studies should establish such procedures to truly appreciate disease-state/age-related changes to connective tissue dynamics.
Our protocols also improve upon existing μ-CT modalities for visualising tendon structure, providing the ability to segment both fascicles and IFM from 3D reconstructions. Previous studies using contrast agents have presented procedures to segment and identify some but not all fascicles, but tendon structure could not be fully resolved . However, sample drying using the HMDS protocol presented here provided adequate contrast for segmentation of both fascicles and IFM in both species and allowed quantification of IFM volume and thickness in equine SDFT. By modifying a reverse clarification procedure and combining with a chemical drying process, we present a method that allows cleared tendons to be imaged using contrast-enhanced μ-CT, facilitated by HMDS desiccation. This provides a rapid, cost-effective, non-specialised approach for μ-CT scanning, providing excellent contrast of tendon structure in both large and small animal models. However, we were unable to measure IFM volume in the rat Achilles, as the smaller IFM thickness in this tendon meant that, during segmentation, we were unable to discern between IFM and noise created by HMDS drying. Despite this caveat, this is the first study to report such methods for IFM volumetric measurements using μ-CT, finding that IFM represents a small volume of tendon (5–6%). Using segments derived from equine SDFT, we have also shown that mean IFM thickness, as measured by μ-CT, was between 19 and 22 μm for both HMDS-dried and bimodally imaged samples. This is in agreement with a previous study that described IFM thickness in the equine SDFT as measuring between 10 and 25 μm depending tendon regions , although we could not distinguish between IFM surrounding fascicles and fascicle bundles.
Another benefit to our bimodal workflow is the potential reduction in sample, and therefore animal, numbers required. Our approach nullifies the need for two distinct samples for two separate analysis techniques, providing the potential to reduce the number of animals used for scientific research, in line with the 3Rs principle . Our methodology can also be implemented into pre-existing equipment workflows for confocal microscopy and μ-CT, and can integrate open-source options in the absence of specialist software, such as Icy software for 3D whole-mount fluorescence visualisation and ImageJ/BoneJ for tendon morphometric analyses [44, 45]. Given we have only utilised one clarification method, future studies could investigate the effects of other clearing agents on tendon clarification, however other studies have compared a range of clearing solutions reporting no or limited effects on clearing of skeletally mature tendons [12, 15]. As clearing agents can have a tissue-specific effect, there is a greater need for understanding how clarification agents impact tendon ultrastructure, with previous studies demonstrating the destructive effects of different clearing agents when imaging GFP-labelled intestine samples . Here, we have not directly determined whether tendon ultrastructure was affected, but no visual differences in tendon macroscopic structure were apparent pre/post-clearing and after reverse clarification. Our Visikol-based procedure also provides flexibility, with multiple stopping points throughout the protocol for both short and long-term storage without deterioration prior to clearing.
To enhance our methodology, 3D image registration of confocal and μ-CT images could be used for localisation of cellular and structural features of soft tissues such as tendon, whilst also enabling the identification of alterations in tissue sub-structure, such as basement membranes, with ageing and injury models. By combining imaging modalities, our method could visualise and analyse spatiotemporal differences in 3D, and would allow identification of injury-induced changes remote from injury site, especially for large animal tissues . These approaches have already been attempted in renal and cardiac injuries in adult mice, demonstrating that 3D approaches can inform regional differences in tissue repair [48, 49]. Hence, our proposed protocol could be scaled down for smaller samples, such as mouse Achilles tendon, to investigate regional differences in cell-ECM interactions in murine models of tendon injury using 3D whole-mount preparation. Furthermore, antibody detection and novel RNA in situ hybridisation techniques could be used in conjunction with 3D registration to establish 3D molecular maps of localised soft tissue markers as evidenced in the developing chick heart . Future studies could also pursue other potentially useful imaging modalities that could inform soft tissue structure-function relationships. For example, reversed clarified tissues can be histologically prepared for quantitative polarised light microscopy (qPLM) to investigate the structural arrangement of collagen and other fibrous proteins [51,52,53]. Therefore, 3D visualisation, image registration and subsequent analyses utilising bimodal imaging would greatly improve evaluation of a wide range of pre-clinical connective tissue disease models, as well as clinical samples.
To the authors’ knowledge, whole-mount fluorescent imaging of tendon has only been described in mouse embryonic tendons using transgenic systems , which pose little difficulty for 3D imaging due to immature collagens/ECM, smaller size, and visualisation via GFP-labelling. However, no such method has been described for the clearing of fluorescently-immunolabelled adult tendons from larger species where transgenic systems may not be financially or technically feasible. Despite this, our method does have some limitations. Firstly, antibody penetration appeared to differ in tendons from different species, with penetration throughout the depth of the rat Achilles (approximately 800 μm) but limited to 200 μm in the equine SDFT, potentially due to lower surface area to volume ratio reducing ability for antibody diffusion. Similar limitations have been reported in osteochondral tissues labelled for large molecular weight ECM proteins, which also reported working depth as an issue for deep musculoskeletal tissue imaging . Despite this, our method significantly improves upon the 20–25 μm imaging depth achieved in the SDFT without clarification reported previously [56, 57]. We also note that scanning large regions of SDFT and whole rat Achilles was performed at low magnification due to working distance of the objective, such that it was not possible to fully resolve cellular structures.
Limitations relating to μ-CT are also present in our method, mostly relating to scanning resolution. Segmentation of smaller structures and IFM remain a challenge despite the high resolution used to scan samples in this study. We found scans at a resolution of 1.6 μm provided high enough resolution to identify tendon sub-structures in both species, although quantification was not possible in rat Achilles tendon. While we were able to visualise IFM in the rat Achilles, the segmentation process generated some noise that we could not distinguish from IFM due to the smaller IFM size in rat compared to equine tendon. Therefore, quantification was not performed, as specialised segmentation procedures will need to be developed to improve filtering of noise in these small samples. As for automatic segmentation of equine SDFT, a small amount of IFM appears to be lost as a result of smoothing and filtering of 2D slices. In our 3D analyses, IFM thickness is calculated as a single mean value, therefore overall distribution of IFM thickness could not be described. Finally, we observed a small amount of shrinkage in both rat and equine tissues, despite this, our measures of IFM thickness are consistent with previous reports, therefore our method provides a viable approach to visualise and measure tendon morphometry using μ-CT.
To overcome these issues in either species, future scans could utilise higher-resolution or synchrotron-sourced x-ray tomography that offer greater imaging power. We also found that scanning without filters and using 180° projections provided the best acquisition of IFM in reconstructed images with reasonable scan time. Despite the aforementioned limitations, our approach permits sub-4-h scans using benchtop μ-CT for downstream 3D volumetric analyses. Future studies could explore the benefits of various filters on scanning power when imaging tendon, whilst improvements to segmentation could be made with specialised segmentation routines such as adaptive local thresholding or machine-learning based segmentation . We also noted that, while HMDS desiccation eliminated external artefacts observed previously when scanning samples in air , we did observe some x-ray ring artefacts in the μ-CT scans. This is most likely a side effect of the drying process itself as well as not using a filter during scans, however these artefacts were easily removed by automated reconstruction, ring smoothing and segmentation and as such do not pose any problems during 3D visualisation or analysis.
Conclusions and Perspectives
We report a novel bimodal imaging approach that utilises non-destructive, reversible clarification for 3D confocal microscopy of tendon which can be coupled with μ-CT procedures for analysis of tendon morphology. This methodology is a valuable addition to the imaging tools currently available to investigate both cellular and molecular biology of soft tissues, particularly in studies of comparative tendon biology to establish conserved structures and cell niche composition. By establishing a clarification protocol that enables study of tendon and other dense connective tissues, we address the lack of cost- and time-effective 3D fluorescent modalities for adult tissues. The introduction of chemical drying as a novel μ-CT preparation to enhance contrast of tendon structure provides the capacity to visualise and quantify tendon sub-structural features. Furthermore, both modalities can be performed independently of each other depending on experimental need and hypotheses. In conclusion, our bimodal imaging approach provides the capacity to visualise and analyse soft tissue structures, an advance which is likely to assist in pre-clinical or clinical investigation of connective tissue structure and pathologies.
Materials and Methods
Achilles tendons were collected from female Wistar rats (age = 13 weeks, n = 2), euthanised for a related tendon injury study in which contralateral uninjured tendons were not required for analysis. Tendons were washed in Dulbecco’s phosphate buffered saline (DPBS), fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde for 24 h at RT and stored in PBS with 0.05% (w/v) sodium azide at 4 °C until processing. Forelimb SDFT were collected from female horses (n = 2, age = 7 and 23 years) euthanised at a commercial abattoir for reasons unrelated to tendon injury. Pieces (approximately 5 mm × 5 mm × 2 mm) were isolated from the mid-metacarpal region of the tendon, washed briefly in DPBS supplemented with 1% (v/v) antibiotic-antimycotic solution and fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde/10% neutral buffered formalin at RT for 24 h. Samples were stored in 70% ethanol at 4 °C until processing.
Fluorescent Immunolabelling and Clarifying Procedures
Prior to whole-mount preparations, serial sections of equine SDFT and rat Achilles were fluorescently labelled with LAMA4 to validate expression in 2D and optimise antibody concentrations (see Supplementary Methods). For preparation of immunolabelled samples, equine SDFT segments and whole rat Achilles were processed according to Visikol™ guidelines. All steps were performed with orbital agitation at 60 RPM. SDFT segments were washed twice for 12 h with tris buffered saline (TBS) at RT, and permeabilised sequentially in 50% (v/v) methanol: TBS, 80% (v/v) methanol:dH2O, and 100% methanol for 2 h at 4 °C. Samples were washed sequentially for 40 min at 4 °C with 20% (v/v) dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO):methanol, 80% (v/v) methanol:dH2O, 50% (v/v) methanol: TBS, TBS, and TBS supplemented with 0.2% (v/v) Triton X-100 (0.2% TBS-TX100).
For rat Achilles tendons, permeabilisation was performed as described for equine SDFT, with the exception that DPBS was substituted for TBS in all steps. Use of either saline solution does not impact labelling of tissue.
Prior to blocking, samples were incubated with a pre-blocking penetration buffer containing 0.2% TBS-TX100, 0.3 M glycine, and 20% DMSO for 6 h at 37 °C. Equine SDFT segments were blocked for 80 h at 37 °C in 0.2% TBS-TX100 supplemented with 6% (v/v) goat and 6% (v/v) donkey serum and 10% (v/v) DMSO. For rat Achilles tendons, blocking was performed in 0.2% TBS-TX100 supplemented with 6% (v/v) goat serum and 10% (v/v) DMSO. Primary antibody incubations for rabbit anti-LAMA4 (1:200; STJ93891, St. John’s Laboratories) for equine SDFT and 1:100 for rat Achilles tendons were performed at 37 °C for 80 h in respective antibody buffer containing TBS supplemented with TWEEN20 (0.2% v/v; TBS-TWEEN20), 3% (v/v) goat serum, 3% (v/v) donkey serum, and 5% (v/v) DMSO. For rat Achilles tendon antibody incubations, donkey serum was omitted.
Samples were washed three times for 2 h in wash buffer containing TBS-TWEEN20. Secondary antibody incubation was performed with goat anti-rabbit Alexa Fluor® 594 (A11037, Fisher Scientific) diluted at 1:250 for equine SDFT and 1:500 for rat Achilles tendon in antibody buffer for 36 h for equine SDFT and 72 h for rat Achilles tendon at 37 °C. Samples were washed five times for at least five minutes with wash buffer, before an overnight wash in wash buffer supplemented with 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole dihydrochloride (DAPI; 1:2000) for cell nuclei counterstaining. Samples were dehydrated as described above with increasing concentrations of methanol. Two-step tissue clarification was performed by immersing samples in Visikol HISTO-1 for 36 h for equine SDFT and 72 h for rat Achilles, followed by immersion in HISTO-2 for at least 36 h at RT. Samples were stored in HISTO-2 at 4 °C prior to confocal imaging.
Samples were immersed in HISTO-2 on a glass-bottom dish fitted with a silicone chamber for imaging. Serial optical sections (equine SDFT z-stack = 200 μm; rat Achilles tendon z-stack = 1000–1500 μm) were acquired using a Leica TCS SP8 laser scanning confocal microscope with a motorised stage. Images were acquired with a HC PL FLUOTAR 10x/0.32 dry objective lens at a resolution of 1024 × 1,024 px, pinhole size set to 1 Airy unit, frame average set to 1, line average set to 8, and electronic zoom set to 0.75. Sequential scans of samples (rat Achilles: approx. 7 mm × 2 mm × 1.5 mm; equine SDFT: approx. 1 mm × 1 mm × 0.2 mm) were captured using lasers emitting light at 405 (blue channel; DAPI) and 561 (red channel; Alexa Fluor 594) nm to detect fluorescent signal, with low laser power (< 10%), and scanning speed set to 600 Hz. 3D rendering, segmentation, and projections were performed and visualised using Leica LAS X software (version 3.5.5) within the 3D module. Figures were produced using Inkscape (version 0.92).
Reverse Clarification and Chemical Drying for X-Ray Micro-Computed Tomography
Reverse clearing of tissues post confocal imaging were performed by sequential washes for a minimum of 3 h in 30, 50, 70, 80, 90, 96, and 100% (v/v) ethanol. Samples were immersed in HMDS solution (SIGMA: 52619) for 3–6 h and air-dried at room temperature overnight prior to X-ray micro-computed tomography.
X-Ray Micro-Computed Tomography (μ-CT)
HDMS-dried equine SDFT and rat Achilles samples were affixed to a brass holder using dental wax and scanned using a Skyscan 1172F (version 1.5, Skyscan, Kontich, Belgium) with X-ray source at 40 kV tube voltage and 250 μA tube current with 1815 ms exposure time and 1.6 μm voxel size. 180° scans were performed with no filter, frame averaging at 5, with a rotation step at 0.2° and random movement set to 20. Slice reconstruction was performed in NRecon (version 18.104.22.168). Grey scale and false-colour volume renderings were produced using CTVox (version 3.3.0, Bruker, Belgium).
3D Analysis of Tendon IFM
3D analysis of equine SDFT pieces were performed using a cylindrical volume-of-interest (VOI) of 1.75 mm × 1.75 mm × 2 mm on all samples to avoid regions damaged by gross dissection of tendon. To process tendon plugs for 3D analysis, reconstructed images were processed using CTAn (version 22.214.171.124). To analyse tendon structure, we adapted existing workflows for bone analysis in CTAn (Table 1), to measure the volume of scanned tendon (TV), IFM volume (IV), relative IFM volume to tendon volume (IV/TV), and IFM thickness (IFM.Th). For 3D colour mapping of IFM thickness, BV and Tb.th were adapted as measures of IFM volume and thickness. These measurements were then used for 3D reconstruction and colour coded in CTVox (version 3.3.0). Graphs were produced in GraphPad Prism (version 8.0.0).
Availability of Data and Materials
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
x-ray micro-computed tomography
Dulbecco’s phosphate-buffered saline
Superficial digital flexor tendon
Tris-buffered saline supplemented with tween20
Tris-buffered saline supplemented with triton-× 100
Kerstens A, Corthout N, Pavie B, Huang Z, Vernaillen F, Vande Velde G, et al. A label-free multicolor optical surface tomography (ALMOST) imaging method for nontransparent 3D samples. BMC Biol. 2019 Jan 7;17(1):1.
Ban S, Cho NH, Min E, Bae JK, Ahn Y, Shin S, et al. Label-free optical projection tomography for quantitative three-dimensional anatomy of mouse embryo. J Biophotonics. 2019;12(7):e201800481. https://doi.org/10.1002/jbio.201800481.
Clark JN, Garbout A, Ferreira SA, Javaheri B, Pitsillides AA, Rankin SM, et al. Propagation phase-contrast micro-computed tomography allows laboratory-based three-dimensional imaging of articular cartilage down to the cellular level. Osteoarthr Cartil. 2020 Jan;28(1):102–11.
Metscher BD. MicroCT for comparative morphology: simple staining methods allow high-contrast 3D imaging of diverse non-mineralized animal tissues. BMC Physiol. 2009 Jun 22;9(1):11.
Godinho MSC, Thorpe CT, Greenwald SE, Screen HRC. Elastin is localised to the Interfascicular matrix of energy storing tendons and becomes increasingly disorganised with ageing. Sci Rep. 2017;7(1):1–11.
Chatterjee S. Artefacts in histopathology. J Oral Maxillofac Pathol. 2014 Sep;18(Suppl 1):S111–6.
Luo Y, Li N, Chen H, Fernandez GE, Warburton D, Moats R, et al. Spatial and temporal changes in extracellular elastin and laminin distribution during lung alveolar development. Sci Rep. 2018;8(1):1–12.
Nombela-Arrieta C, Pivarnik G, Winkel B, Canty KJ, Harley B, Mahoney JE, et al. Quantitative imaging of haematopoietic stem and progenitor cell localization and hypoxic status in the bone marrow microenvironment. Nat Cell Biol. 2013 May;15(5):533–43.
Greenbaum A, Chan KY, Dobreva T, Brown D, Balani DH, Boyce R, et al. Bone CLARITY: Clearing, imaging, and computational analysis of osteoprogenitors within intact bone marrow. Sci Transl Med. 2017;9(387):eaah6518. https://doi.org/10.1126/scitranslmed.aah6518.
Zhang W, Liu S, Zhang W, Hu W, Jiang M, Tamadon A, et al. Skeletal Muscle CLARITY: A Preliminary Study of Imaging The Three-Dimensional Architecture of Blood Vessels and Neurons. Cell J. 2018;20(2):132-7. https://doi.org/0.22074/cellj.2018.5266.
Hama H, Hioki H, Namiki K, Hoshida T, Kurokawa H, Ishidate F, et al. Sca l eS: an optical clearing palette for biological imaging. Nat Neurosci. 2015;18(10):1518–29.
Berke IM, Miola JP, David MA, Smith MK, Price C. Seeing through musculoskeletal tissues: improving in situ imaging of bone and the lacunar Canalicular system through optical clearing. PLoS One. 2016 Mar 1;11(3):e0150268.
Kuwajima T, Sitko AA, Bhansali P, Jurgens C, Guido W, Mason C. ClearT: a detergent- and solvent-free clearing method for neuronal and non-neuronal tissue. Development. 2013 Mar 15;140(6):1364–8.
Calve S, Ready A, Huppenbauer C, Main R, Neu CP. Optical Clearing in Dense Connective Tissues to Visualize Cellular Connectivity In Situ. PLoS One. 2015;10(1):e0116662. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0116662.
Milgroom A, Ralston E. Clearing skeletal muscle with CLARITY for light microscopy imaging. Cell Biol Int. 2016 Apr 1;40(4):478–83.
Yeh AT, Choi B, Nelson JS, Tromberg BJ. Reversible dissociation of collagen in tissues. J Investig Dermatol. 2003;121(6):1332–5.
Villani TS, Koroch AR, Simon JE. An improved clearing and mounting solution to replace chloral hydrate in microscopic applications. Appl Plant Sci. 2013;1(5):1300016.
Sargent J, Roberts V, Gaffney J, Frias A. Clarification and confocal imaging of the nonhuman primate placental micro-anatomy. BioTechniques. 2018;66(2):79–84.
Merz G, Schwenk V, Shah RG, Necaise P, Salafia CM. Clarification and 3-D visualization of immunolabeled human placenta villi. Placenta. 2017 May 1;53:36–9.
Arck PC. When 3 Rs meet a forth R: replacement, reduction and refinement of animals in research on reproduction. J Reprod Immunol. 2019 Apr 1;132:54–9.
Balint R, Lowe T, Shearer T. Optimal Contrast Agent Staining of Ligaments and Tendons for X-Ray Computed Tomography. PLoS One. 2016;11(4):e0153552. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0153552.
Crica LE, Wengenroth J, Tiainen H, Ionita M, Haugen HJ. Enhanced X-ray absorption for micro-CT analysis of low density polymers. J Biomater Sci Polym Ed. 2016 Jun 12;27(9):805–23.
Alba-Alejandre I, Hunter WB, Alba-Tercedor J. Micro-CT study of male genitalia and reproductive system of the Asian citrus psyllid, Diaphorina citri Kuwayama, 1908 (Insecta: Hemiptera, Liviidae). PLoS One. 2018 Aug 16;13(8):e0202234.
Varghese B, Luo J, Skorka T, Zhou B, Crandall E, Conti P, et al. Volumetric Micro-Computed Tomographic Imaging of Lung Anatomy. J Nucl Med. 2015;56(supplement 3):2516.
Rieppo L, Karhula S, Thevenot J, Hadjab I, Quenneville E, Garon M, et al. Determination of extracellular matrix orientation of articular cartilage in 3D using micro-computed tomography. Osteoarthr Cartil. 2017 Apr 1;25:S254.
Paterson GLJ, Sykes D, Faulwetter S, Merk R, Ahmed F, Hawkins LE, et al. The pros and cons of using micro-computed tomography in gross and microanatomical assessments of polychaetous annelids. In: Memoirs of Museum Victoria; 2014;71:237–46. https://doi.org/10.24199/j.mmv.2014.71.18.
Mai C, Verleden SE, McDonough JE, Willems S, De Wever W, Coolen J, et al. Thin-section CT features of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis correlated with micro-CT and histologic analysis. Radiology. 2016;283(1):252–63.
Kestilä I, Thevenot J, Finnilä MA, Karhula SS, Hadjab I, Kauppinen S, et al. In vitro method for 3D morphometry of human articular cartilage chondrons based on micro-computed tomography. Osteoarthr Cartil. 2018 Aug 1;26(8):1118–26.
Thorpe CT, Birch HL, Clegg PD, Screen HRC. The role of the non-collagenous matrix in tendon function. Int J Exp Pathol. 2013 Aug;94(4):248–59.
Sanes JR. The basement membrane/basal Lamina of skeletal muscle. J Biol Chem. 2003 Apr 11;278(15):12601–4.
Iozzo RV. Basement membrane proteoglycans: from cellar to ceiling. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2005 Aug;6(8):646–56.
Timpl R, Rohde H, Robey PG, Rennard SI, Foidart JM, Martin GR. Laminin--a glycoprotein from basement membranes. J Biol Chem. 1979 Oct 10;254(19):9933–7.
Hohenester E, Yurchenco PD. Laminins in basement membrane assembly. Cell Adhes Migr. 2013 Jan 1;7(1):56–63.
Taylor SH, Al-Youha S, Van Agtmael T, Lu Y, Wong J, McGrouther DA, et al. Tendon Is Covered by a Basement Membrane Epithelium That Is Required for Cell Retention and the Prevention of Adhesion Formation. PLoS ONE. 2011;6(1):e16337.
Jozsa L, Lehto M, Kannus P, Kvist M, Reffy A, Vieno T, et al. Fibronectin and laminin in Achilles tendon. Acta Orthop Scand. 1989 Jan 1;60(4):469–71.
Thorpe CT, Peffers MJ, Simpson D, Halliwell E, Screen HRC, Clegg PD. Anatomical heterogeneity of tendon: fascicular and interfascicular tendon compartments have distinct proteomic composition. Sci Rep. 2016 Feb 4;6(1):20455.
Kestilä I, Finnilä MA, Karhula SS, Rieppo L, Lehenkari P, Thevenot J, et al. 3D analysis of chondron morphology of human and rat articular cartilage from micro-computed tomography. Osteoarthr Cartil. 2016 Apr 1;24:S298.
Bouxsein ML, Boyd SK, Christiansen BA, Guldberg RE, Jepsen KJ, Müller R. Guidelines for assessment of bone microstructure in rodents using micro–computed tomography. J Bone Miner Res. 2010 Jul 1;25(7):1468–86.
Ali OJ, Comerford EJ, Clegg PD, Canty-Laird EG. Variations during ageing in the three-dimensional anatomical arrangement of fascicles within the equine superficial digital flexor tendon. Eur Cell Mater. 2018;35:87–102.
Wragg JW, Finnity JP, Anderson JA, Ferguson HJM, Porfiri E, Bhatt RI, et al. MCAM and LAMA4 are highly enriched in tumor blood vessels of renal cell carcinoma and predict patient outcome. Cancer Res. 2016 Apr 15;76(8):2314–26.
Thyboll J, Kortesmaa J, Cao R, Soininen R, Wang L, Iivanainen A, et al. Deletion of the Laminin α4 chain leads to impaired microvessel maturation. Mol Cell Biol. 2002 Feb 15;22(4):1194–202.
Vaicik MK, Blagajcevic A, Ye H, Morse MC, Yang F, Goddi A, et al. The absence of Laminin α4 in male mice Results in enhanced energy expenditure and increased beige subcutaneous adipose tissue. Endocrinology. 2017;159(1):356–67.
Susek KH, Korpos E, Huppert J, Wu C, Savelyeva I, Rosenbauer F, et al. Bone marrow laminins influence hematopoietic stem and progenitor cell cycling and homing to the bone marrow. Matrix Biol. 2018 Apr 1;67:47–62.
Doube M, Kłosowski MM, Arganda-Carreras I, Cordelières FP, Dougherty RP, Jackson JS, et al. BoneJ: free and extensible bone image analysis in ImageJ. Bone. 2010 Dec;47(6):1076–9.
de Chaumont F, Dallongeville S, Chenouard N, Hervé N, Pop S, Provoost T, et al. Icy: an open bioimage informatics platform for extended reproducible research. Nat Methods. 2012 Jul;9(7):690–6.
Bossolani GDP, Pintelon I, Detrez JD, Buckinx R, Thys S, Zanoni JN, et al. Comparative analysis reveals Ce3D as optimal clearing method for in toto imaging of the mouse intestine. Neurogastroenterol Motility. 2019 May 1;31(5):e13560.
Biasutti S, Dart A, Smith M, Blaker C, Clarke E, Jeffcott L, et al. Spatiotemporal variations in gene expression, histology and biomechanics in an ovine model of tendinopathy. PLOS ONE. 2017;12(10):e0185282.
Hasegawa S, Susaki EA, Tanaka T, Komaba H, Wada T, Fukagawa M, et al. Comprehensive three-dimensional analysis (CUBIC-kidney) visualizes abnormal renal sympathetic nerves after ischemia/reperfusion injury. Kidney Int. 2019 Jul 1;96(1):129–38.
Merz SF, Korste S, Bornemann L, Michel L, Stock P, Squire A, et al. Contemporaneous 3D characterization of acute and chronic myocardial I/R injury and response. Nat Commun. 2019;10(1):1–14.
Anderson C, Hill B, Lu H-C, Moverley A, Yang Y, Oliveira NMM, et al. A 3D molecular atlas of the chick embryonic heart. Dev Biol. 2019 Dec;456(1):40–6.
Ritty TM, Ditsios K, Starcher BC. Distribution of the elastic fiber and associated proteins in flexor tendon reflects function. Anat Rec. 2002 Dec 1;268(4):430–40.
Thorpe CT, Karunaseelan KJ, Ng Chieng Hin J, Riley GP, Birch HL, Clegg PD, et al. Distribution of proteins within different compartments of tendon varies according to tendon type. J Anat. 2016;229(3):450–8.
Spiesz EM, Thorpe CT, Thurner PJ, Screen HRC. Structure and collagen crimp patterns of functionally distinct equine tendons, revealed by quantitative polarised light microscopy (qPLM). Acta Biomater. 2018 Apr 1;70:281–92.
Huang AH, Watson SS, Wang L, Baker BM, Akiyama H, Brigande JV, et al. Requirement for scleraxis in the recruitment of mesenchymal progenitors during embryonic tendon elongation. Development. 2019;146:dev182782. https://doi.org/10.1242/dev.182782.
Neu CP, Novak T, Gilliland KF, Marshall P, Calve S. Optical clearing in collagen- and proteoglycan-rich osteochondral tissues. Osteoarthr Cartil. 2015 Mar 1;23(3):405–13.
Thorpe CT, Riley GP, Birch HL, Clegg PD, Screen HRC. Effect of fatigue loading on structure and functional behaviour of fascicles from energy-storing tendons. Acta Biomater. 2014;10(7):3217–24.
Thorpe CT, Riley GP, Birch HL, Clegg PD, Screen HRC. Fascicles from energy-storing tendons show an age-specific response to cyclic fatigue loading. J R Soc Interface. 2014 Mar 6;11(92):20131058.
Chityala R, Pudipeddi S, Arensten L, Hui S. Segmentation and visualization of a large, high-resolution micro-CT data of mice. J Digit Imaging. 2013 Apr 1;26(2):302–8.
Faulwetter S, Vasileiadou A, Kouratoras M, Dailianis T, Arvanitidis C. Micro-computed tomography: Introducing new dimensions to taxonomy. Zookeys. 2013;(263):1–45.
NM is funded by the Royal Veterinary College Mellon fund for equine research; CTT is funded by a Versus Arthritis Career Development Fellowship (Grant Number 21216).
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Rat Achilles tendons were obtained as waste tissue from a related study which was approved by the Royal Veterinary College ethics committee, conducted under a Home Office licence (PB78F43EE) and complied with the Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act (1986). Collection of equine tendon was approved prior to commencement of the project by the Royal Veterinary College Ethics and Welfare Committee (URN-2016-1627b). Tendons were sourced from horses euthanised for reasons other than tendon injury at a commercial equine abattoir as a by-product of agricultural industry. The Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986, Schedule 2, does not define collection from these sources as a scientific procedure.
Consent for Publication
All authors confirm they have no financial or non-financial competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Schematic showing data collection and analysis workflows for confocal microscopy and x-ray microtomography. Supplementary Fig. 2: Representative 2D sections of equine superficial digital flexor and rat Achilles tendons, immunolabelled for LAMA4. Longitudinal sections were immunolabelled for LAMA4, using a primary antibody concentration of 1:200 in the equine SDFT (a) and 1:100 in the rat Achilles (c), detected with alexa-594 conjugated secondary antibody (1:500) and nuclei counterstained with DAPI. Negative controls, in which primary antibodies were omitted, were performed for both species (equine SDFT, b; rat Achilles, d). Scale bar = 100 μm.
About this article
Cite this article
Marr, N., Hopkinson, M., Hibbert, A.P. et al. Bimodal Whole-Mount Imaging of Tendon Using Confocal Microscopy and X-ray Micro-Computed Tomography. Biol Proced Online 22, 13 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12575-020-00126-4
- Interfascicular matrix
- Optical clarification
- Confocal microscopy
- X-ray micro-computed tomography